What does the odometer law state regarding the replacement of an odometer?

The odometer law actually permits the replacement of an odometer under specific conditions, making "it is unlawful to replace an odometer under any circumstance" an inaccurate interpretation of the law. The correct answer is that it is permissible to replace an odometer with proper documentation. This allows for the transparency and accuracy that protect consumers when vehicle ownership changes.

When an odometer is replaced, it is essential to document the replacement correctly to maintain an accurate vehicle history. This documentation typically includes information about the mileage at the time of the replacement and ensures that any potential buyer is aware of the vehicle's history. By requiring proper documentation, the law protects consumers from odometer fraud, ensuring that they have access to a vehicle's true mileage.

In addition, while calibration or reporting to authorities may be part of specific legal obligations in certain jurisdictions, the fundamental principle is to ensure that any replacement of an odometer is transparent and well documented, which is not captured in the claim that it is unlawful to do so under any circumstance.